https://doi.org/10.37955/cs.v8i3.359
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Analysis of motivations and
challenges to responsible pet
ownership
Análisis de motivaciones y desafío hacia la tenencia
responsable de animales de compañía
Edgar David Parrales Zambrano
Msc. Universidad Agraria del Ecuador edgar.paredes@uae.edu.ec,
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7912-5284
William E. Rosas Carrera
Msc. Universidad Agraria del Ecuador William.carrera@uae.edu.ec
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1128-6062
Israel E. Márquez Cabrera
Msc. Universidad Agraria del Ecuador, Israel.marquez@uae.edu.ec
https://orcid.org/0009-0004-9874-9518
Cesar Carrillo Cedeño
Msc. Universidad Agraria del Ecuador, cesar.carrillo@uae.edu.ec,
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0369-5154
ABSTRACT
The objective of this study was to evaluate the impact of physical
environmental enrichment on the agonistic behavior of 30 cats housed
in the "Rescue Mission" shelter. In the pre-enrichment period, a
significant increase in agonistic behaviors was observed, such as 205
paw swipes and 184 vocalizations. After implementing crates and
shelves as enrichment, a gradual reduction of these behaviors was
recorded. Comparison of the two types of enrichment revealed that the
cats preferred the 282 boxes over the 170 shelves. As for the
relationship between enrichment and sex, age and body condition of
the cats, statistically significant relationships were found. Taken
together, these results point to the significant influence of sex, age, and
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3- JulySeptember - Revista Centro Sur - eISSN: 2600-5743
2
122
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
body condition on cats' environmental enrichment preferences. These
findings highlight the importance of environmental enrichment in
improving the welfare of cats in shelters and homes, and provide
relevant information for decision making in the management of these
animals. It is concluded that the implementation of effective
environmental enrichment strategies can reduce stress and improve
the behavior of cats, promoting a more harmonious coexistence
among felines.
RESUMEN
Este estudio tuvo como objetivo evaluar el impacto del
enriquecimiento ambiental físico en el comportamiento agonístico de
los 30 gatos alojados en el refugio "Misión Rescata". En el periodo pre-
enriquecimiento, se observó un aumento significativo de
comportamientos agonísticos, como 205 golpes con una pata y 184
vocalizaciones. Tras implementar cajas y estanterías como
enriquecimiento, se registró una reducción gradual de estos
comportamientos. La comparación de los dos tipos de
enriquecimiento reveló que los gatos prefirieron las 282 cajas en lugar
de las 170 estanterías. En cuanto a la relación entre el enriquecimiento
y el sexo, la edad y la condición corporal de los gatos, se encontraron
relaciones estadísticamente significativas. En conjunto, estos
resultados apuntan a la influencia significativa del sexo, la edad y la
condición corporal en las preferencias de enriquecimiento ambiental
de los gatos. Estos hallazgos destacan la importancia del
enriquecimiento ambiental para mejorar el bienestar de los gatos en
refugios y hogares, y proporcionan información relevante para la toma
de decisiones en el manejo de estos animales. Se concluye que la
implementación de estrategias efectivas de enriquecimiento ambiental
puede reducir el estrés y mejorar el comportamiento de los gatos,
promoviendo una convivencia más armoniosa entre los felinos.
Keywords / Palabras clave
animal welfare, agonistic behavior, environmental enrichment, cats,
shelter
Bienestar animal, comportamiento agonístico, enriquecimiento
ambiental, gatos, refugio
2
123
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Introduction
The definition of environmental enrichment, as expressed by Ellis,
Molinero and Vatios (2022), is any addition to the environment in
which an animal is found to produce an improvement of the
environment by adding an assurance of animal welfare. Dare (2021)
defines environmental enrichment as the set of dynamic activities that
are designed to improve the mental and physical health, and meet the
ethological and psychological needs of an animal, highlighting the
importance of the process of environmental suitability in creating an
overall welfare that meets the natural behavioral needs of animals.
Behavior is an organism's response to stimuli. Salonen (2020)
indicates that this behavior is variable among individuals and consists
of different traits, such as aggressiveness, fear, among others.
Implying that it is usually influenced by genes, the behavior of an
individual is also manifested through environmental factors. In the
specific case of cats, as described by Alley Cat Allies (2017), their
behavior has two main sources: instinctive and learned. It is complex
to clearly differentiate these two behaviors, given that this species
constantly adjusts its behavior through learning and observation.
In this context, Toscano and Menor (2020) point out that an animal
shelter is a public or private place that aims to provide protection,
control and care for companion animals that do not have a permanent
home. These establishments provide facilities to house animals and
promote their adoption, as well as veterinary care services, adequate
food, and recreational space. Wagner, Hurley, and Stavisky (2018),
emphasize the importance of shelters and rehoming centers, as they
contribute to population management and facilitate the rehoming of
species that are homeless or have lost their homes. These institutions
play a valuable role in animal welfare and in finding new homes for
those animals in need.
Domestic cats have become popular as pets, however, Liu, Paterson,
Camarri, Murray, and Phillips (2020) report that many are
surrendered to shelters or welfare organizations, or at worst
abandoned on the streets or in parks. In a specific approach to the
research, cats have become very popular for adoption as pets, however,
there is a high rate of cats on the streets, either due to abandonment,
loss or escape, among others. In a specific approach to the situation in
Ecuador, Lopez (2021) points out that animal abandonment has
increased significantly due to the COVID-19 pandemic. This increase
2
124
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
has led to shelters being in a chronic situation, having to house a
considerable number of animals, ranging from 20 to 100, which
represents a challenge for the capacity and resources of these shelters.
In 2019, Lingna conducted research entitled "Enrichment strategies
that modify cat behavioral pattern: their applications in improving
welfare". The aim of her study was to apply effective short- and long-
term environmental enrichment strategies, focusing on assessing the
preferences of scratcher types (corded or cardboard) and their
influence on cats' scratching behavior.
Their research findings indicated that feline stimulants, such as catnip,
were effective in increasing scratching and other interactions between
cats and scratchers. The use of these stimuli was helpful in redirecting
scratching behavior and provided a form of environmental enrichment
that promoted increased activity and variety of behaviors in the cats.
In research titled "Exploring improvements in the welfare of shelter
cats through environmental enrichment options," conducted by Ellis,
Stryhn, Spears, and Cockram in 2017, various forms of environmental
enrichment were examined with the purpose of identifying those that
generate greater welfare in cats housed in shelters. The study sought
to determine which types of enrichment are best suited to meet the
specific needs of these animals in such environments.
Different types of enrichment were implemented, including a no-
stimulus control group, a toy simulating prey, perches, and hide-and-
seek boxes. Through quantitative data recording and behavioral
observation, it was observed that the cats showed a significant
preference for the hide-and-seek boxes compared to the other types of
enrichment used. In addition, it was noted that cats frequented these
enrichments more during the light period than during the dark period.
De Toni (2020), through his study of "Environmental enrichment for
domestic cats (Felis catus Linnero, 1758): Applications of techniques
to improve feline welfare", highlights the relevance of environmental
enrichment. The results of their study revealed that, one week after
applying the enrichment program, the cats' behaviors returned to the
pattern observed prior to implementing enrichment. This suggests
that, in order to develop an effective program, it is crucial to create an
environment with enrichment on an ongoing basis, taking into account
the observed behaviors. That is, enrichment must be in line with the
cats' natural needs and behaviors to achieve a lasting impact on their
well-being.
2
125
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Research by Lingna (2019), Ellis and colleagues (2017) and De Toni
(2020) have concluded that the application of environmental
enrichment in cat shelters has a positive impact on their behavior. By
studying feline responses to different types of environmental
enrichment, information is gained about the cats' preferences and
needs, which in turn significantly improves their well-being. These
studies demonstrate that appropriate enrichment can be a valuable
tool for promoting a more enriching and satisfying environment for
cats in shelters.
A shelter, according to Lopez (2021), is a place with the purpose of
offering protection and care to animals that have been rescued or
received after being abandoned or mistreated in their previous homes.
These shelters provide temporary shelter to animals until they are
adopted, giving them shelter and a sense of security and peace of mind.
People who decide to adopt an animal from these shelters must take
responsibility for caring for the animal's needs to ensure its optimal
well-being.
When designing a shelter, it is important to consider several key
factors. The National Veterinary Academy (2021) highlights that these
crucial aspects include the welfare of the animals, the safety of the
staff, and the needs of those caring for the animals in the shelter. In
addition, it emphasizes the need to establish a protocol for each stage
of the process, from rescue or admission of the animal to its
subsequent adoption. This would include aspects such as quarantine,
vaccination and establishment of daily routines for the care of the
animals. These elements are essential to ensure a safe and healthy
environment for the animals, as well as to facilitate the adoption
process and their overall well-being.
Internationally, guidelines for the care of animals in shelters have been
approved. Muñoz (2020), emphasizes that these guidelines were
established by the Association of Shelter Veterinarians with the
purpose of providing a reference adaptable to each specific
environment and situation, focusing mainly on animal welfare.
Figueroa (2021), defines Animal Welfare as the capacity in which an
animal species adapts to the environment and its conditions, which
implies that the animal is in a healthy state, adequately nourished,
comfortable, without fear or pain, safe and expresses its natural
behavior. In the planning and operation of a shelter, it is essential to
put animal welfare as a priority.
2
126
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Toscano (2020), considers that an environment in the shelter that
does not have appropriate conditions, adding a deprivation of stimuli,
damages the normal behavioral patterns of the animals, manifesting
stress and consequently stereotyped behaviors, together with other
manifestations of discomfort.
According to the research conducted by Ellis and Wells (2017), the
importance of the principle of freedom of expression in the welfare of
animals in shelters is highlighted, especially for felines. In addition,
the principles of freedom from fear and distress are mentioned, as well
as freedom from physical or thermal discomfort, which are also
fundamental to ensure adequate environmental enrichment.
Knowledge of species-specific behaviors is crucial to avoid potential
problems and negative consequences.
Animal welfare is a topic of great importance and has been the subject
of several research studies. One example is the study by Mariti et al.
(2020), in which a detailed observation of environmental and
behavioral changes in cats housed in shelters that received different
forms of human contact was conducted. This research sought to
understand how human contact affects the welfare of cats in a shelter
environment.
On the other hand, Barnett et al. (2018) conducted a study on
environmental enrichment for adult cats, evaluating the effects of two
treat-based methods on feline welfare. This type of research is relevant
to identify which approaches can improve the quality of life of adult
cats in captive environments, such as shelters or homes.
For Toscano and Menor (2020), it is of utmost importance to
understand the environmental elements that can have a negative
impact on the behavior of cats in confined spaces, affecting their
overall well-being. These environmental needs are divided into two
categories: the macroenvironment and the microenvironment. The
macroenvironment refers to the external environment that cats
perceive from their cage, either the room around them or the area in
which they are located. On the other hand, the microenvironment
refers directly to the cage itself in which they are housed, considering
both its physical conditions and the objects present inside. It has been
shown that, by improving the environment through environmental
enrichment, it is possible to reduce negative behaviors related to stress
in these felines.
2
127
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Environmental needs in the feline species, as noted by Bennett,
Paterson, and Walker (2020), play a crucial role in the well-being and
quality of life of shelter cats. The provision of an enriched environment
and a routine-based care program can have a significant impact on the
physical and mental health of these animals.
An enriched environment for cats involves providing a variety of
stimuli and opportunities that meet their natural needs. Ellis and
Carney (2021), stress, this can include the availability of climbing and
hiding spaces, interactive toys that encourage physical and mental
activity, and areas for scratching and nail sharpening. In addition, an
enriched environment can allow cats to explore and express their
natural hunting and foraging behavior. However, Toscano and Menor
(2020) indicate that through domestication, cats have become more
closely related to humans and to their own species and can live
together with them, i.e., they have become social beings. With this, it
has become possible to relate cats with other cats in a shelter and they
structure a certain hierarchy that maintains respect among felines.
The authors explain that cats, regardless of the number of individuals
in the group, usually show signs of stress between week one of entering
the shelter compared to other cats that have been housed in this place
for between two to sixteen weeks, so it is evident that the adaptation
period upon entering a shelter takes approximately two weeks.
Toscano and Menor (2020), indicate that it has been found that cats
have an inclination towards a microenvironment that offers heights
and places of concealment, such as boxes or cages. By having this type
of enrichment in their immediate environment, cats tend to exhibit a
calmer attitude and show less reluctance to interact with humans.
They are also observed to exhibit caring and closeness behaviors.
The microenvironment plays a crucial role in the well-being of cats in
shelters, according to Bennett, Dowling, and Casey (2018). This
concept refers to the closest and most direct environment in which
felines find themselves, i.e., the physical space of the cage or assigned
area in the shelter. To enhance the well-being of cats in this
environment, it is essential to provide elements that enrich their
experience, such as heights, hiding places, interactive toys, and
suitable substrates. These elements allow cats to express their natural
behaviors, such as climbing, hiding, exploring and playing, which
reduces the stress and anxiety associated with shelter confinement. In
addition, ensuring proper cleanliness and organization of the
microenvironment is also essential to promote the health and well-
2
128
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
being of the cats while they are waiting to be adopted or reunited with
their owners.
In addition to studying cats' preferences for a microenvironment,
Toscano and Menor (2020) state that it is important to consider both
the microenvironment and the macroenvironment when enriching the
cat's environment. If only the microenvironment is enhanced without
attention to the macroenvironment, cats are likely to show greater
apathy and adopt more apathetic, avoidant and agonistic behaviors.
Conversely, when both the macroenvironment and microenvironment
are enriched, cats exhibit self-care behaviors and show greater
affiliation.
The macroenvironment, as mentioned by Carney, Little, and
Brownlee-Tomasso (2019), plays a significant role in the behavior of
cats toward humans and other felids in environments such as shelters
and homes. This concept encompasses the broader environment that
cats perceive from their cage or designated space, i.e., the outdoor
environment surrounding them. The design and organization of the
macroenvironment can influence cats' socialization, affecting how
they interact with people and other feline companions.
An enriched macroenvironment can include socialization zones, where
cats have the opportunity to interact with other members of their
species in a controlled and safe environment. It can also provide
opportunities for interaction with humans, which builds the cats'
confidence and sociability. In addition, a well-planned
macroenvironment can provide sensory stimulation, such as outdoor
sights, interesting sounds and smells, which keeps cats engaged and
stimulated. Environmental enrichment for Desforges (2021), is the
importance of improving the species' living environment through
environmental enrichment by providing elements and provisions that
support animal welfare. By enriching the environment, benefits are
achieved both physically, mentally and socially, allowing animals to
exhibit species-appropriate behaviors in a natural way.
Environmental enrichment is a crucial practice to improve the welfare
of refugee cats, especially during their recovery period after becoming
lost. According to Serafini, Bassi, and Faverzani (2018),
environmental enrichment consists of providing these felines with a
series of elements and provisions that enrich their environment and
satisfy their physical and psychological needs. In a temporary shelter
environment, it is critical to provide cats with opportunities to express
2
129
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
their natural behaviors, such as scratching, exploring, hunting, and
maintaining social interactions with other individuals. By ensuring an
enriched environment, the activity, curiosity and general well-being of
shelter cats are encouraged, allowing them to better adapt to their new
situation and facilitating their recovery process.
To enrich a cat's environment, Foreman and Farnworth (2019),
emphasize the need to understand the preferences and actions that
cats typically perform in their natural outdoor environment in order to
enrich their environment. These actions include scratching, climbing
or climbing, hunting, exploring, hiding, inquiring, foraging, and
socializing with other individuals. Understanding these behaviors is
essential to ensure optimal welfare and to allow cats to express their
innate behaviors in the place where they are housed.
Ellis, et al. (2022), stress the importance of having a meticulous
approach when applying environmental enrichment. To achieve this
goal, it is recommended to employ an enrichment plan that has been
previously analyzed and approved, which can be applied in a
generalized manner for all cats. This will allow prioritization of a wide
variety of behaviors in meeting the needs of the animals.
In relation to this, Yupa (2018) emphasizes that an environmental
enrichment plan should have a solid foundation in the physical
environment, considering factors such as available space, objects
intended for play and feeding, as well as the cat's social structure and
interaction with humans. To ensure successful implementation of
environmental enrichment, it is essential to study the specific
behavioral needs of each cat species and provide materials that
simulate the conditions they would encounter in a natural, free
environment.
Shelter environmental enrichment programs, as outlined by
Bremhorst, Tighe, and Starling (2019), play an essential role in the
welfare and successful adoption of cats. These programs are designed
to enhance the living environment of felines in shelters by providing
physical and mental stimulation that encourages natural and positive
behaviors.
By implementing environmental enrichment programs, shelters can
offer cats a variety of activities and opportunities to explore, play and
socialize. This can include the availability of interactive toys, climbing
and hiding structures, and socialization areas where cats can interact
with other feline companions and humans.
2
130
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Clinical ethology according to Zhukova, et al. (2021), focuses on the
study of animal behavior, with the purpose of understanding the
formation of similar behavioral patterns between different species.
Comparisons of these patterns are also carried out both between
species and between individuals. In addition, the relationships that
individuals establish with others of the same species, with different
species and with the surrounding environment are analyzed.
Zailema (2021), the ethogram is presented as a valuable tool that
involves an exhaustive record, both in descriptive and experimental
terms. Its objective is to identify and describe various categories of
behaviors expressed by an individual or a group of individuals in their
natural habitat. With the help of the ethogram, it is possible to classify
the natural behaviors exhibited by animals, considering both acts that
are mutually exclusive and those that are carried out collectively.
Materials and Methods
The study included a quantitative descriptive field research that is
presented with a quantitative nature, since it was determined through
data collection, analysis and interpretation how many times agonistic
behavior patterns were presented when applying two physical
environmental enrichment techniques.
The research design was non-experimental, because the study will be
conducted through observation and description, since the aim is to
determine whether the application of physical environmental
enrichment techniques promotes the increase or decrease of agonistic
behavioral patterns that are mostly presented as a problem at the level
of a shelter and the preference between the two techniques to be used.
Data were recorded by means of tables made in Microsoft Excel. The
data collection for the evaluation of the agonistic behaviors presented
was given by means of Excel record sheets for a period of the day where
the cats show the most activity (Annex 1) that include the listed
agonistic behavior categories that were based on the search and
research of articles and theses, that have applied an ethogram with
categories of agonistic behavior according to this species, for each one
that presented a behavioral pattern were recorded with a +1, and then
counted how many +1 were recorded by putting the total in the
corresponding cell, in case no behavioral pattern was recorded it will
be recorded with a - . They were recorded by means of a program made
in order not to feed the animal's boredom by carrying a monotonous
2
131
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
enrichment. For the measurement of the agonistic behavioral patterns
of the pre-enrichment environmental observation were also evaluated
with a similar table, excluding the enrichments applied, the pre-
enrichment evaluation days will be 5 days (Annex 2).
An ethogram (Annex 3) was also used to evaluate the numerical and
percentage total of agonistic behavior patterns presented before the
enrichment and during the application of the enrichment.
Finally, for the evaluation of the preferences of the cats according to
sex, age and body condition data, towards the two techniques to be
maneuvered on the physical environmental enrichment, which are
boxes and shelves, a table of preference records was used indicating
the data mentioned by each cat of the study (Annex 4), for the total of
the records divided by the categories according to the biological data
(sex: male, female; age: juvenile, adult; CC: 1-9) frequency tables were
made of the total summations by each category (Table 7, Table 8, Table
9). For the evaluation of the preference between boxes and shelves, the
results of the same table (Annex 4) were used excluding data on sex,
age and body condition, i.e., only the number of cats that used these
objects regardless of their biological data was counted.
Results
In the case of relating the age of the cats (Juvenile-Adult) to the type
of environmental enrichment, the associated p-value (0.000016) was
less than the margin of error (0.05). Consequently, significant
statistical evidence was found indicating a relationship between the
age of the cats and the type of environmental enrichment used.
Finally, when relating the body condition of the cats (CC:3, CC:4, CC:5,
CC:6, CC:7) to environmental enrichment, the associated p-value
(0.0000000000213) was less than the margin of error (0.05).
Therefore, he found sufficient statistical evidence to affirm a
significant relationship between the body condition of the cats and the
type of environmental enrichment used.
In this work, a detailed initial evaluation of the behavior of the cats
housed in the "Rescue Mission" shelter was carried out. Through the
use of ethograms and direct camera observations, relevant behavioral
patterns were identified, specifically agonistic behaviors. This initial
phase allowed us to establish a solid basis for investigating the impact
of physical environmental enrichment in reducing such behaviors and
improving the welfare of felines in shelters.
2
132
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
First, it was observed that during the pre-physical environmental
enrichment phase, cats exhibited significant agonistic behaviors, such
as paw tapping (205 times) and vocalizations (184 occasions) over a
five-day evaluation period. These results are consistent with previous
findings by Gajdos et al. (2023), who also found that striking with a
paw and vocalizations were the most frequent agonistic behaviors in
cats. On the other hand, with the implementation of physical
enrichment in the form of boxes and shelves, a marked reduction in
agonistic behaviors was observed. In the first week of enrichment, one-
paw swipes decreased to 83 presentations, vocalizations to 52 and
fighting to 2 presentations. These results are consistent with the study
by Dantas et al. (2017), examined the relationship between agonistic
behavior and environmental enrichment in shelter-housed cats. Their
results suggest that the introduction of a puzzle feeder as enrichment
did not lead to an increase in aggression due to competition for
resources. This supports the idea that environmental enrichment can
provide opportunities for exploratory behaviors and improve welfare
in groups of cats housed long-term in shelters or multi-cat
environments, as also demonstrated in the present research.
Comparing the results of this research with the study by Zailema
(2021), which evaluated the behavior of cats in a shelter, there is a
similarity in the presence of agonistic behaviors in felids in both
situations. This suggests that shelter cats in both our study and
Zailema's study may experience behavioral problems related to
aggression, in both the most presented agonistic behavior was
vocalizations. This could indicate the importance of implementing
environmental enrichment strategies to improve welfare and reduce
agonistic interactions in shelters and similar environments.
The results obtained where two types of physical environmental
enrichment were compared show that the cats in the study exhibited
different behavioral patterns in relation to the use of boxes and shelves
as forms of environmental enrichment. In the case of boxes, most cats
(mode) used them approximately 12 times, with a mean value of 9.4
times. Some cats showed no interest in the boxes (minimum), while
others used them up to 22 times (maximum). The data revealed a
dispersion in relation to the mean of about 5.46, a variance of 29.77
and a standard deviation of 5.46. On the other hand, in the case of
shelving as a form of enrichment, the results indicate that many cats
played around 6 times, as reflected in the mode. The mean was 5.7
times, which points to an overall average of use. The standard
deviation of 4.10 suggests moderate variability in the data, while the
median of 5.5 indicates an even distribution of frequency of use. Based
2
133
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
on these results, it can be concluded that cats showed a slightly higher
preference for the use of boxes as a form of environmental enrichment
compared to shelves. However, it is important to note that the
variability in the data suggests that some cats may have preferred
shelves at certain times or circumstances. These findings are
consistent with the results of Ellis et al. (2017), who also found that
cats showed greater interaction with enclosed, covered spaces, such as
boxes (median:55%), compared to toy interaction (median: 2%). From
an ethological perspective, this preference for boxes may be related to
the natural behavior of felines to seek shelter and safe spaces for
resting and protection. In addition, these results suggest that boxes
may be a more effective and beneficial option as physical
environmental enrichment for cats housed in shelters, as evidenced in
the "Rescue Mission" shelter.
The results of the chi-square statistical analysis provide valuable
information on the relationships between the different types of
physical environmental enrichment and variables such as sex, age and
body condition of the cats. First, when evaluating the relationship
between the sex of the cats and the type of enrichment (Box-Rack), the
associated p-value (0.000033) indicates that there is a significant
association between these two variables. This suggests that the
preference for a specific type of enrichment varies according to the
gender of the cats, which could be due to differences in their natural
behaviors or individual preferences. When examining the relationship
between cat age (Juvenile-Adult) and enrichment type, the associated
p-value (0.000016) points to a statistically significant connection. This
finding suggests that the choice of environmental enrichment is also
influenced by the cats' life stage. Younger and adult cats may have
different needs for stimulation and exploration, which could influence
their preference for certain types of enrichment. Finally, when relating
the cats' body condition to environmental enrichment, the extremely
low p-value (0.0000000000213) suggests a strong relationship
between these two variables. This indicates that preference for one
type of enrichment may be linked to the cats' body condition. It is
possible that cats with different body conditions have specific
enrichment preferences, which could be related to their activity levels,
mobility and comfort.
It can be interpreted that the variation in enrichment preference
between genders of cats could be related to inherent aspects of their
individual behavior and preferences. Cats, as a species, may exhibit
gender-based behavioral differences due to biological and hormonal
2
134
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
factors. Males and females may have different patterns of exploration,
social interaction, and response to environmental stimuli. For
example, in the wild, males may be more likely to explore wider areas
in search of resources, while females may focus more on rearing and
caring for young. These differences may influence how they interact
with different types of enrichment. Some males may prefer more active
activities or stimuli that mimic hunting, while females may opt for
more relaxed environments to rest and care for their well-being.
On the other hand, interpreting the finding of a significant relationship
between cat age and environmental enrichment choice implies that
cats' different life stages play a crucial role in their enrichment
preferences and needs. Younger cats, such as kittens and adolescents,
tend to be more active and curious compared to adult cats. They are in
a learning and developmental phase, which makes them more likely to
seek novel stimuli and explore their environment more energetically.
In this regard, they may show a preference for enrichments that
provide opportunities for play, interaction and active exploration, such
as shelves that allow them to climb and jump. On the other hand, adult
cats, especially those in later stages of life, may have a more relaxed
attitude and may seek out enrichments that provide comfort,
relaxation and resting options. Boxes, for example, might offer them a
quiet, cozy space to rest, hide, and feel safe.
The finding of a significant relationship between cats' body condition
and preference for a particular type of enrichment suggests a close
interaction between cats' physical condition and their enrichment
choices. Cats with a leaner body condition (CC:3) may be more active
and have higher energy levels to explore and participate in stimulating
activities. They may seek out enrichments that allow them to move,
climb and play more intensely, such as shelves that offer opportunities
for jumping and climbing. On the other hand, cats with a heavier body
condition (CC:5-7) may prefer enrichments that provide comfort and
rest, as they may have reduced mobility or may be less inclined to
engage in strenuous physical activities. Boxes might provide them with
a cozy, protected space where they can relax without the need to exert
themselves physically. The connection between enrichment preference
and body condition could also be related to stress levels and well-
being. Cats with higher body condition may experience more stress in
their daily lives, which could influence their preferences for
enrichments that reduce stress and provide them with a safe haven.
2
135
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Comparing these results with those of other studies reviewed, such as
Ellis et al. (2017), Foreman and Farnworth (2019), and De Toni
(2020), there is convergence on the importance of environmental
enrichment for cat welfare. Enrichment provides felids with
opportunities to express natural behaviors and satisfies their physical
and mental needs. The preference for enclosed structures, such as
boxes, and the importance of the enriched environment in the long
term, as mentioned by De Toni (2020), is also confirmed in our results.
On the other hand, Lingna's (2019) study highlights the effectiveness
of sensory enrichment in modifying unwanted behaviors, such as
inappropriate scratching, in cats. This suggests that, in addition to
physical structures, strategies that stimulate cats' senses should also
be considered to improve their well-being. By integrating this
knowledge with our results, it is possible to design more
comprehensive and effective enrichment programs for cats in shelters
and homes, addressing both their physical and emotional needs.
The results of this study provide relevant information for improving
the welfare and behavior of cats housed at the "Rescue Mission"
shelter. Boxes stand out as a more effective and preferred option for
cats compared to shelves. Understanding how the gender, age, and
body condition of cats influence their physical environmental
enrichment preferences provides valuable insights into optimizing
their well-being. By considering gender differences, we can tailor
enriched environments to meet the particular needs of males and
females, taking advantage of their natural behaviors and preferences.
In addition, by adjusting enrichment options according to the cat's life
stage, whether juvenile or adult, we can encourage active participation
and appropriate stimulation. Finally, by taking into account body
condition, we can provide enrichments that align with their activity
and comfort levels, helping to reduce stress and improve their
emotional well-being. Strategic implementation of physical
environmental enrichment based on these variables can enrich cats'
experiences, promoting an active and healthy lifestyle that supports
their individual needs and contributes to their overall happiness.
The results corroborate and align with previous research that has
found that cats prefer enclosed, covered spaces such as boxes,
suggesting an innate need to seek shelter and protection. These
findings are of relevance to improving the care and attention of cats in
shelters and homes. Providing appropriate environmental enrichment
options, such as crates, can help reduce stress, aggression, and other
2
136
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
behavioral problems, improving overall feline well-being. Differential
attention to physical environmental enrichment in refugee cats has a
profound impact on their well-being. By considering preferences
based on sex, age and body condition, an environment is created that
aligns with their individual needs. This can result in reduced stress
levels, more natural behaviors, and a greater sense of security, which
ultimately promotes their emotional and physical well-being in the
shelter environment.
In terms of public health, this personalized approach to physical
environmental enrichment can generate significant positive effects.
Shelter cats that exhibit more balanced and healthy behaviors are
more likely to successfully adapt in adoptive homes. In addition, by
demonstrating an active commitment to animal welfare and
implementing specific strategies based on scientific evidence, shelters
can strengthen their image in the community and foster a culture of
responsible animal care. This, in turn, can increase adoption and
societal involvement in the protection of shelter cats, generating a
positive impact on overall public health.
This study and its comparison with other research highlights the
importance of providing adequate enrichment for cats in shelters and
homes. Reducing stress and improving the well-being of cats can have
positive effects on human-animal coexistence, which could reduce the
likelihood of abandonment and promote responsible ownership. In
addition, an enriched environment for cats may prevent behavioral
problems and aggression, contributing to safer and healthier
interactions between felines and the community at large. Taken
together, these results and their comparison with previous studies
provide a solid basis for the implementation of effective environmental
enrichment strategies aimed at cat welfare and their positive impact
on both veterinary and public health.
Conclusions
In the development of the present study, significant results were
obtained that allow drawing relevant conclusions about the behavior
and environmental enrichment in cats housed in the "Rescue Mission"
shelter.
Regarding the first objective, which sought to evaluate the agonistic
behavior of the cats before and during the implementation of physical
environmental enrichment techniques, it was found that physical
2
137
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
environmental enrichment had a positive impact on the reduction of
agonistic behaviors. During the pre-enrichment phase, a high level of
agonistic behaviors, such as paw tapping (205 times), vocalizations
(184 times), and staring (135 times), was observed. However, after the
implementation of physical environmental enrichment (boxes and
shelves), a significant decrease in agonistic behaviors was evident. Paw
tapping decreased to 83 times, vocalizations to 52 times, and staring
to 41 times in the first week. These results suggest that physical
environmental enrichment is an effective strategy to reduce aggression
in shelter housed cats.
Regarding the second objective, which was to compare two types of
physical environmental enrichment (boxes and shelves), it was found
that cats showed a clear preference for boxes and shelves as forms of
enrichment. Boxes were used on a total of 282 occasions, while shelves
were used on 170 occasions. These numerical data indicate that boxes
were the enrichment option most often chosen by the felids housed in
the shelter. This preference may be due to the fact that boxes provide
a safe and secure shelter space, which meets the cats' natural
behavioral needs.
In the third objective, which sought to evaluate the relationship
between types of physical environmental enrichment with sex, age and
body condition, interesting results were found. The relationship
between type of enrichment and sex of cats (p = 0.000033) highlights
that preferences may vary according to differences in natural
behaviors and individual preferences between males and females. The
statistical relationship between the age of the cats and their choice of
enrichment (p = 0.000016) points to a clear influence of life stages on
the selection of environmental stimuli. Specifically, it highlights how
preferences for certain types of enrichment may be influenced by
different stimulation and exploration needs in young and adult cats.
The highly significant relationship between cats' body condition and
their enrichment preferences (p = 0.0000000000213) is a highly
relevant finding. It indicates that the choice of enrichment may be
directly related to the physical condition of the cats. Speculatively, it
could be inferred that cats with different body conditions might favor
certain types of enrichment due to their specific mobility, comfort and
activity levels.
The results obtained in this study support the effectiveness of physical
environmental enrichment as a strategy to reduce aggressiveness in
cats housed at the "Rescue Mission" shelter. In addition, a clear
2
138
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
preference was found for boxes and shelves as forms of enrichment,
with boxes being the option most used by the felines. These findings
suggest the importance of providing an enriched environment adapted
to the needs of the cats, considering their preferences and individual
characteristics to improve their well-being and quality of life in the
shelter.
References
Academia nacional de Veterinaria (2021). Organización y
funcionamiento de los refugios para animales. 26 (3), 41-46.
Alley Cat Allies. (2017). Biology and Behavior of the cat. Recuperado
de Alleycat.org
Barnett, J. L., Hemsworth, P. H., & Coleman, G. J. (2018).
Environmental enrichment for adult cats: Effects of two treat-
based methods on welfare. Animals, 8(4), 60.
Baquero, J. A. (2017). Comportamiento natural del perro y del gato.
Bennett, V., Dowling, C., & Casey, R. (2018). Feline shelter medicine:
A survey of current practices in the continental United States.
Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 20(4), 309-315.
Bennett, V., Paterson, M., & Walker, S. (2020). The impact of an
enriched environment and a routine-based care program on the
welfare of shelter cats. Animals, 10(7), 1133.
Bremhorst, A., Tighe, A., & Starling, M. (2019). Understanding the
adoption process of cats in animal shelters: An Australian study.
Animals, 9(8), 526.
Bradshaw, J. (2018). Normal feline behaviors... and why behaviors
develop. Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, 20, 411-421.
Bustos, D. (2019). Evaluación de la preferencia respecto a dos
estímulos auditivos diferentes en felinos domésticos. (Tesis de
pregrado). Universidad de las Américas, Chile.
Cafazzo, S., & Pereira, G. (2021). Indoor environmental enrichment for
shelter cats: Current knowledge and future directions. Animals,
11(3), 771.
Carney, H. C., Little, S., & Brownlee-Tomasso, D. (2019). The influence
of socialization practices on cats' behavior toward humans and
other cats. Journal of Applied Animal Welfare Science, 22(2),
159-175.
Dare, P. (2021). The impact of arousing or calming environmental
enrichment during morning cleaning kenneled shelter dogs (tesis
de maestría). Universidad de Nebraska en Omaha, Omaha.
Dantas-Divers, Leticia M. S.; Crowell-Davis, Sharon L.; Alford, Kelly;
Genaro, Gelson; D'Almeida, Jose Mario; Paixao, Rita L. (2017).
2
139
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Agonistic behavior and environmental enrichment of cats
communally housed in a shelter. Journal of the American
Veterinary Medical Association, 239(6), 796–802.
De Toni, B. (2020). Enriquecimiento ambiental para gatos domésticos
(Felis catus Linnaeus, 1758): Aplicacoes de técnicas para
melhoria do bemestar felino. (Tesis de pregrado). Universidad de
Caxias do sul, Brazil.
Desforges, E. (2021). Challenges and Solutions Surrounding
Environmental Enrichment for Dogs and Cats in a Scientific
Environment. Animals, 11, 2980, 1-11.
Dudas, S. (2019). Impacts of physical and social environments on the
behavior and welfare of domestic cats. Animals, 9(10), 884.
Ellis, J., Molinero, K., Vatios, K. (2022). Feline Enrichment. Animal
Behavior for Shelter Veterinarians and Staff.
Ellis, J., Stryhn, H., Spears, J., Cockram, M. (2017). Environmental
enrichment choices of shelter cats. Behavioural
Processes,141(3),291-296.
Espindola, V., Silva, N. (2022). Enriquecimiento ambiental mínimo
para gatos em amniente de internacao-Relato de caso.
Veterinária e Zootecnia, 29, 1-6.
Fediaf. (2021). Facts and Figures 2021. Fediaf Euripean Pet Food.
Forsytwi, A. (2019). Guía para el diseño y manejo de un albergue para
animales. The Veterinary Clinics of North America, 35 (3), 675-
698.
Gajdoš-Kmecová, N., Peťková, B., Kottferová, J. et al. (2023). An
ethological analysis of close-contact inter-cat interactions
determining if cats are playing, fighting, or something in
between. Sci Rep 13, 92.
Guitérrez, G., Granados, D., & Piar, N. (2017). Interacciones humano-
animal: características e implicaciones para el bienestar de los
humanos. Revista Colombiana de Psicología, 16(1), 163-184.
Grant, R., Rose, J. (2018). Clicker Training Increases exploratory
behaviour and time spent at the front of ther enclosure in shlter
cats; implications for welfare and adoption rates. Applied Animal
Behavior Science, 18, 159-168.
Hampton, A., Ford, A., Roy, E., Chin-chi, L., Ronald, K. (2019). Effects
of music on behavior and physiological stress response of
domestic cats in a veterinary clinic. Journal of Feline Medicine
and Surgery, 1-7.
Keizer, K., van den Broek, M., & Schilder, M. (2019). Can clicker
training facilitate the adoption of shelter cats? Applied Animal
Behaviour Science, 219, 104837.
2
140
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Kristyn, R., Vitale, S., Monique, A. (2017). Stress, security, and scent:
The influence of chemical signals on the social lives of domestic
cats and implications for applied settings. Applied Animal
Behaviour Science, 187, 69-76.
Lawson, G., Langford, F., Harvey, A. (2019). The environmental needs
of many Australian pet cats are not being met. Journal of Feline
Medicine and Surgery, 1-9.
Litchfield, C. A., Quinton, G., Tindle, H., Chiera, B., Kikillus, H., &
Roetman, P. (2020). Cats in the clinic: What the veterinarian
needs to know about cat behavior in a caged environment.
Animals, 10(6), 1011.
Liu, S., Paterson, M., Camarri, S., Murray, L., Phillips, C. (2020). The
effects of the frequency and method of gentling on the behavior
of cats in shelters. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 39, 47-56.
López, M. (2021). Re-Diseño del refugio de animales KODAH para
mejorar la calidad de vida de los refugiados y los trabajadores
ubicado en el cantón Cevallos-Tungurahua. (Tesis de pregrado).
Universidad Técnica de Ambato, Ecuador.
Mariti, C., Ciceroni, C., Gazzano, A., Moore, J. L., & Sighieri, C. (2020).
An observational study of environmental and behavioural
changes in shelter cats provided with different forms of human
contact. Animals, 10(6), 1095.
Muñoz, M. (2020). Propuesta de implementación de un sistema de
aseguramiento de calidad de Bienestar animal, basada en la
Norma ISO 26000 y en un HACCP en el albergue criar en el
periodo marzo-junio 2020. (Tesis de pregrado). Universidad de
las Americas.
Municipio de Guayaquil (2022), Censo realizado por Municipio revela
que en Guayaquil habitan 770.000 mascotas. Alcaldía Guayaquil.
Ottoni, C., Van Neer, W., De Cupere, B., et al. (2017). The
palaeogenetics of cat dispersal in the ancient world. Nat Ecol
Evol, 1: 139.
Penar, W., Klocek, C. (2018). Aggressive behaviors in domestic cats
(Felis catus). Animal Science 57(2), 143-150.
Rendón H., D., Quintana M., E., Door M., I., Vicuña A., F., León C., D.,
& Falcón P., N. (2018). Parámetros demográficos en la población
de canes y gatos domésticos en asentamientos humanos del
distrito de Ventanilla, Callao-Perú. Revista de Investigaciones
Veterinarias Del Perú, 29(1), 217.
Rosado, B., García, S., Luño, I., González, Á. (2021). Reducción del
Miedo y estrés durante la hospitalización. B Braun VetCare, 121,
4-13.
2
141
Received Febrary 12, 2024/ Approved April 13, 2024 Pages: 121-141
eISSN: 2600-5743
Centro Sur Vol. 8 No. 3 – July - September
Salonen, M. (2020). The genetic, demographic, and environmental
factors of cat and dogs behaviour (tesis doctoral). Universidad de
Helsinki, Folkhalsan.
Serafini, M., Bassi, E., & Faverzani, S. (2018). Assessing the welfare of
cats living in temporary housing during their recovery after being
lost. Animals, 8(10), 182.
Sciabarrasi, A., Sensevy, A., Cervantes, G., Scaglione, M., Cerutti,
R.(2020). Influencia del enriquecimiento ambiental en las
conductas de Felis catus, Leopardus geoffrogy y Puma
yaguarundi. Revista Colombiana Cienc Anim. Recia, 12(2), 1-13.
Toscano, C. & Menor, D. (2020). Enriquecimeinto ambiental en
refugios y albergues para gatos (Felis silvestris catus). (Tesis de
pregrado). Universidad de Córdoba, Argentina.
Vitale, K. (2022). Increasing Shelter Cat Welfare Thorugh
Enrichement: A Revew. ResearchGate 248 (9).
Wagner, D., Hurley, K., Stavisky, J. (2018). Shelter housing for cats.
Principles of desing for health, welfare and rehoming. Journal of
Feline Medicine and Surgery, 20, 635-642.
Yupa, A. (2018). Evaluación de cnicas de enriquecimiento ambiental
y su influencia en el comportamiento y bienestar de gatos
alojados en refugio. (Tesis de pregado). Universidad de
Guayaquil, Ecuador.
Zailema, V. (2021). Evaluación conductual en felinos en un centro de
rescate animal, Guayaquil. (Tesis de pregrado). Universidad
Agraria del Ecuador.
Zhao, J., Vernier-Singer, M., Fitzgerald, R. (2017). Environmental
enrichment for shelter cats: Exploring the role of artificial plants.
Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 18, 22-30.
Zhang, J., Wade, C., & Hofman, S. (2021). A comparative analysis of
the environmental preferences of cats and dogs at a zoological
park. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 238, 105175.
Zimmerman, P., & Jana, N. (2020). The effects of color and orientation
of cats on the human-cat relationship. Journal of Veterinary
Behavior, 40, 24-29.
Zito, S., Walker, J., Gates, M., Dale, A., & Bennett, P. (2018). Cat
ownership in New Zealand: Prevalence, and owner and cat
characteristics. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 23, 33-39.